Skip to content
May 29, 2023
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Youtube
DFRAC_ORG

DFRAC_ORG

Digital Forensics, Research and Analytics Center

Primary Menu
  • Home
  • Fact Check
  • Hate Monitor
  • Opinion
  • Hashtag Scanner
  • News
  • Podcasts
  • About
    • About Us
    • Contact us
    • Our Team
    • Non-Partisanship Policy
    • Privacy Policy
    • Resources
  • हिन्दी
  • English
  • اردو
Live
  • Featured
  • Opinion

How much did Britain actually take away from India?

DFRAC Editor August 14, 2021 3 min read

On May 28, 2015, Shashi Tharoor the Indian Politician and Author, gave a speech at Oxford Union. In this speech he criticizes the British Colonial Rule for damaging the Indian economy.

Tharoor claimed that India’s share of the global economy declined from 23% to 4 % under the British. This claim is supported by the acclaimed historian Angus Maddison’s research. India’s global industrial output too declined from 25% in 1750 to 2% in 1900. Why did this happen when it is largely believed that India benefited from the British rule in introducing the country to industrialization and the ways of the modern world?

Global Economy vs Year
Global Industrial Output vs Year

There are a lot of reasons for this apparent decline. While agriculture did expand under their rule, so did poverty and farmers who incurred debt because they were forced to cultivate opium. Opium comes from poppy and is a cash crop. This impacted at least 10 million people in the region now called Uttar Pradesh and Bihar, in completely demolishing their livelihood because of land taxes and other costs incurred upon them by the British. Thousands of Indians died at these opium factories because of lack of safety precautions.

A surprising fact to be noted here is that Indians actually made up a large chunk of the British Army during the First and Second World Wars. The first world war cost India 8 billion pounds. In addition to this, Britain owed India 1.25 billion pounds after the war ended, but this debt was never repaid.

A major clue about how Britain exploited India is witnessed in the famines that occurred during the British rule. It is estimated that about 15-30 million people died due these famines. The number of deaths could have been largely reduced had the British government not diverted resources from the region to Europe to be stored as mere “stock reserves”

The severe economic mismanagement however, was not completely overlooked by the British. Opposition party leader at the time, Edmund Burke who in 1778 began a 7 year long trial against Warren Hastings and the East India Company on the charges of economic mismanagement in India.

While it is largely believed that the British rule was responsible for deindustrialization in India, the main part of Tharoor’s speech actually focused on how the impact of this social, economic and political exploitation can be mitigated.

Reparations

Reparations are described as a kind of compensation paid for abuse or injury caused by an entity. In the past, reparations were paid by the side that lost a war which was displayed at the end of World War 1 when Germany and its allies had to pay billions of dollars in reparations. The term now is largely understood at the compensation provided to those whose human rights have been violated. Now, reparations can be of many types including sums of money to be paid to the victims or even providing them with resources that the person or the community need. Various examples of reparations have been witnessed in the past.

The government of Canada paid 350 million dollars to indigenous people of the country who faced discriminations and harassment by the hands of the government. Tharoor however points out the need for Britain to acknowledge the moral debt incurred by them rather than engaging in the act of restorative justice.

So, if Britain was to pay India back for the centuries of damage and deaths it caused to the nation, how much would that amount actually be? Renowned economist, Utsa Patnaik estimates this amount to be a whopping 44.6 trillion dollars, 20 times the size of Britain’s GDP.

Through Patnaik’s work, it is clear that Britain did not in any way develop India, but it was India who developed Britain. This independence day, we ask you a question, should Britain pay India back for all that it did to its people?

Share this…
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Whatsapp

DFRAC Editor

Digital Forensics, Research and Analytics Centre (DFRAC) is a non-partisan and independent media organisation which focuses on fact-checking and identifying hate speech. With the popularisation of the internet came the challenge of information overload and often times, our feeds are overpopulated with conflicting, incendiary and false information which is increasingly becoming difficult to ignore and not believe in

See author's posts

Continue Reading

Previous: Fact-Check: New media Twitter account with 1.5 Lakh followers posts fake and misleading news
Next: Filmmaker Vivek Agnihotri posts fake quote by CM of Punjab calling the farmer protest pro-Khalistan and pro-Pakistan

Related Stories

Video of students made to offer namaz went viral with the misleading claim – Read Fact Check
1 min read
  • Fact Check
  • Featured
  • Misleading

Video of students made to offer namaz went viral with the misleading claim – Read Fact Check

May 29, 2023
Kolkata Express: A Story of How a Fake Media Outlet Started Deceiving People
6 min read
  • Featured
  • Hate

Kolkata Express: A Story of How a Fake Media Outlet Started Deceiving People

May 26, 2023
Is Amul selling spoil products? – Fact Check busts the claims
2 min read
  • Fact Check
  • Fake
  • Featured

Is Amul selling spoil products? – Fact Check busts the claims

May 26, 2023

Popular post

fact check

Video of students made to offer namaz went viral with the misleading claim – Read Fact Check

Video of students made to offer namaz went viral with the misleading claim – Read Fact Check

May 29, 2023
Kolkata Express: A Story of How a Fake Media Outlet Started Deceiving People

Kolkata Express: A Story of How a Fake Media Outlet Started Deceiving People

May 26, 2023
Is Amul selling spoil products? – Fact Check busts the claims

Is Amul selling spoil products? – Fact Check busts the claims

May 26, 2023
A misleading picture of the Tricolour is shared on social media as Sydney welcomes the new India. – Read Fact Check

A misleading picture of the Tricolour is shared on social media as Sydney welcomes the new India. – Read Fact Check

May 26, 2023
Fake images of an explosion at Pentagon got viral – Read Fact Check

Fake images of an explosion at Pentagon got viral – Read Fact Check

May 24, 2023
Did Muslims kill an RSS worker inside a mosque in Kerala? Read – Fact Check

Did Muslims kill an RSS worker inside a mosque in Kerala? Read – Fact Check

May 24, 2023

Connect with Us

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Youtube

News

Video of students made to offer namaz went viral with the misleading claim – Read Fact Check
1 min read
  • Fact Check
  • Featured
  • Misleading

Video of students made to offer namaz went viral with the misleading claim – Read Fact Check

May 29, 2023
Kolkata Express: A Story of How a Fake Media Outlet Started Deceiving People
6 min read
  • Featured
  • Hate

Kolkata Express: A Story of How a Fake Media Outlet Started Deceiving People

May 26, 2023
Is Amul selling spoil products? – Fact Check busts the claims
2 min read
  • Fact Check
  • Fake
  • Featured

Is Amul selling spoil products? – Fact Check busts the claims

May 26, 2023
A misleading picture of the Tricolour is shared on social media as Sydney welcomes the new India. – Read Fact Check
1 min read
  • Fact Check
  • Featured
  • Misleading

A misleading picture of the Tricolour is shared on social media as Sydney welcomes the new India. – Read Fact Check

May 26, 2023

IFCN certified

Newsletter

Tags

#factcheckenglish #HijabRow #russianinvasion #russiaukrainwar #Ukrainecrisis Afghanistan Akhilesh Yadav Bangladesh Bharatiya Janta Party (BJP) BJP China Congress Covid 19 DFRAC Facebook Fact Check Factcheck Fake Fake news Hate Hate Speech Hindu Hindu-Muslim INC India Indian Instagram Misinformation Misleading Muslim Muslims NDTV Pakistan Rahul Gandhi RSS Social media Sudarshan News Twitter ukraine UP UP Election UP Police Uttar Pradesh Video Yogi Adityanath

recent post

  • Video of students made to offer namaz went viral with the misleading claim – Read Fact Check
  • Kolkata Express: A Story of How a Fake Media Outlet Started Deceiving People
  • Is Amul selling spoil products? – Fact Check busts the claims
  • A misleading picture of the Tricolour is shared on social media as Sydney welcomes the new India. – Read Fact Check
  • Fake images of an explosion at Pentagon got viral – Read Fact Check
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Non-Partisanship Policy
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Youtube
Copyright © 2023 | All rights reserved | Designed by | MoreNews by AF themes.